Choosing the right portable oxygen concentrator can greatly improve your quality of life and independence. The Philips SimplyGo portable oxygen concentrator and Inogen One are two of the most trusted names in portable oxygen therapy, each with its own advantages for different patient needs.
When deciding between these top oxygen concentrators, it’s important to know the key differences. The Philips SimplyGo portable oxygen concentrator offers flexible oxygen delivery options with both continuous flow and pulse dose capabilities, making it ideal for patients who need therapy all day long. On the other hand, the Inogen One G3 is known for its lightweight design and excellent portability, making it perfect for active users who require pulse dose oxygen.
Your specific requirements for oxygen therapy, lifestyle preferences, and mobility needs will determine which device is best for you. Here are some factors to consider:
- Oxygen delivery modes: What type of delivery method do you need based on your prescription?
- Weight considerations: How much weight can you comfortably carry on a daily basis?
- Battery life expectations: How long do you expect your battery to last for uninterrupted therapy?
- Noise levels: Are there any specific environments where noise levels may affect your comfort?
By understanding the differences between the Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One, you can make an informed decision about which portable oxygen concentrator is right for you. This knowledge will help ensure that your individual oxygen therapy needs are met and that you can continue with your daily activities without any interruptions.
What Are the Key Differences in Oxygen Delivery Between Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One?
Understanding oxygen delivery modes is crucial when deciding between these two portable oxygen concentrators. Each device has its own way of delivering therapeutic oxygen, which directly affects the patient’s treatment results.
Continuous Flow vs Pulse Dose Delivery
- Continuous flow oxygen delivers a steady stream of oxygen regardless of your breathing pattern. This mode provides constant oxygen supply, making it essential for patients who require uninterrupted therapy, particularly during sleep when breathing patterns become irregular.
- Pulse dose delivery operates differently by detecting your inhalation and releasing a measured oxygen bolus only when you breathe in. This intelligent system conserves oxygen and extends battery life whilst maintaining therapeutic effectiveness for many patients.
Delivery Modes of Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One G3
The Philips SimplyGo stands out with its dual delivery capability:
- Continuous flow: 0.5–2 LPM settings
- Pulse dose: Settings 1–6
This versatility allows you to switch between modes based on your current needs or activity level.
The Inogen One G3 focuses exclusively on pulse dose delivery with oxygen therapy settings ranging from 1–5. This specialised approach makes the device lighter and more energy-efficient.
Impact on Usage Patterns
These differences in delivery modes have a significant effect on how the devices are used. If you need oxygen therapy during the night or have specific medical conditions that require continuous flow, the SimplyGo’s dual functionality becomes crucial. On the other hand, patients who primarily need support during the day while being active often find the Inogen One G3’s pulse dose system perfectly sufficient for their lifestyle needs.
Who Is Each Portable Oxygen Concentrator Best Suited For?
Usage suitability varies significantly between these two devices based on your specific oxygen therapy needs. The Philips SimplyGo serves patients who require continuous oxygen users support, particularly those needing uninterrupted oxygen delivery during sleep or rest periods. You’ll find this device essential if your prescription includes 24/7 oxygen therapy, as its dual delivery capability ensures consistent oxygen flow regardless of your breathing patterns.
The device excels for patients with:
- Sleep-related breathing disorders requiring continuous flow
- Higher oxygen demands exceeding pulse dose capabilities
- Medical conditions necessitating round-the-clock oxygen support
- Nighttime oxygen therapy requirements
The Inogen One G3 targets mobile users seeking maximum portability without compromising therapy effectiveness. You’ll appreciate this concentrator if your lifestyle demands frequent travel, outdoor activities, or extended periods away from home power sources. Its lightweight design and extended battery life make it ideal for active individuals who refuse to let oxygen therapy limit their mobility.
Perfect candidates for the Inogen One G3 include:
- Active patients with pulse dose prescriptions
- Frequent travellers requiring reliable portable oxygen
- Users prioritising discretion and minimal weight burden
- Individuals with stable oxygen requirements during daytime activities
Your lifestyle and medical needs directly influence device choice. Sedentary patients or those with severe respiratory conditions typically benefit from SimplyGo’s continuous flow capability, while active users with stable conditions often prefer the Inogen One G3’s superior portability and battery endurance.
How Do Weight and Portability Compare Between Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One?
Device weight represents one of the most significant differences between these two oxygen concentrators. The Philips SimplyGo weighs approximately 10 pounds, making it substantially heavier than the Inogen One G3, which tips the scales at just 4.8-4.9 pounds. This weight difference of roughly 5 pounds can dramatically affect your daily activities and mobility.
The portability advantage clearly favours the Inogen One G3. You can easily carry this lighter unit in a shoulder bag or backpack without experiencing significant fatigue during extended periods. The SimplyGo’s additional weight requires more consideration when planning activities or travel arrangements.
Carrying options help offset the SimplyGo’s weight disadvantage. Philips includes a sturdy carrying bag with padded straps, and you can purchase an optional wheeled cart that transforms the unit into a rolling suitcase-style device. These accessories make transportation more manageable, particularly through airports or during longer walking distances.
The travel-friendly design of both units accommodates different user preferences. The Inogen One G3’s compact size and lighter weight make it ideal for spontaneous outings and active lifestyles. The SimplyGo’s wheeled cart option provides excellent mobility for users who prioritise continuous flow capability over minimal weight.
Your physical strength, activity level, and daily routine should guide your choice between these Philips SimplyGo vs Inogen One models, as weight directly impacts your independence and quality of life.
What Are the Battery Life Differences and Their Impact on Usage?
Battery life is one of the most important factors to consider when choosing between these portable oxygen concentrators. It directly affects your freedom and ability to continue therapy throughout the day.
Inogen One G3 Battery Life
The Inogen One G3 has an impressive battery system with 16 cells, allowing it to last up to 8 hours on pulse dose setting 2. This means you can go about your day without worrying about finding a place to recharge.
Philips SimplyGo Battery Life
The Philips SimplyGo has different battery performance depending on how you choose to use it:
- Pulse dose battery performance: Approximately 3 hours at setting 2
- Continuous flow battery performance: Around 1.6 hours at 1 LPM
With these shorter battery durations, you’ll need to plan your activities around charging opportunities or bring along extra batteries for longer outings.
How Battery Life Affects Your Daily Routine
The differences in battery life can have a big impact on your daily routine:
- With the Inogen One G3’s longer battery life, you can confidently attend work meetings, social gatherings, or shopping trips without worrying about running out of power. The device allows for uninterrupted therapy during extended periods away from power sources.
- SimplyGo users who require continuous flow therapy may face greater limitations with their battery life. This could restrict spontaneous activities or require careful planning when it comes to managing power. You might need to find places where you can charge your device during longer outings or invest in additional battery packs to maintain your independence in therapy.
Ultimately, these differences in battery life will help determine which device better suits your lifestyle and mobility needs.
How Do Oxygen Output Levels Affect Therapy Effectiveness?
Oxygen output capacity is a critical factor in determining whether a portable concentrator can meet your specific therapeutic requirements. The Philips SimplyGo delivers significantly higher ml/min oxygen delivery at up to 2000 ml/min, while the Inogen One G3 provides up to 1050 ml/min maximum output.
This substantial difference in oxygen production capacity directly impacts therapeutic effectiveness for patients with varying oxygen demands. You’ll find the SimplyGo’s higher output particularly beneficial if you require:
- Elevated oxygen levels during physical activity or exertion
- Continuous flow therapy at higher settings
- Backup capacity for periods of increased oxygen needs
The Inogen One G3’s 1050 ml/min output proves adequate for many patients using pulse dose delivery, especially those with moderate oxygen requirements. However, patients with severe respiratory conditions or those experiencing frequent desaturation episodes may find the SimplyGo’s doubled oxygen production capacity essential for maintaining proper blood oxygen levels.
Your prescribed oxygen flow rate and delivery method will ultimately determine which device’s output capacity aligns with your therapeutic needs. Higher output doesn’t automatically mean better therapy—it means greater flexibility to accommodate varying oxygen demands throughout your daily activities.
What Are the Noise Level Differences Between These Portable Oxygen Concentrators?
The device noise level represents a crucial factor when selecting between these oxygen concentrators, particularly for users who value discretion and comfort during daily activities. The Philips SimplyGo vs Inogen One: Comparing Leading Oxygen Concentrators reveals notable differences in their decibel rating during operation.
The Philips SimplyGo operates at approximately 43 decibels at setting 2, producing a gentle hum comparable to a quiet library environment. In contrast, the Inogen One G3 delivers quieter operation under 39 decibels, making it one of the most discreet portable oxygen concentrators available.
Quiet operation benefits extend beyond mere convenience:
- Enhanced social comfort – Lower noise levels reduce self-consciousness in restaurants, theatres, and social gatherings
- Improved sleep quality – Quieter devices cause less disruption during nighttime use
- Professional environments – Minimal noise allows confident use in workplace settings
- Travel discretion – Reduced attention from fellow passengers during flights or public transport
The 4-decibel difference between these devices may seem minimal, yet you’ll notice this distinction in quiet environments. The Inogen One G3’s superior noise performance makes it particularly appealing for users prioritising stealth operation during active lifestyles or professional commitments.
What Warranty Coverage Do Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One Offer?
Both the Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One G3 provide identical warranty terms for their main units, offering comprehensive three-year coverage from the date of purchase. This extended warranty period demonstrates the manufacturers’ confidence in their product reliability and provides you with substantial protection for your investment.
What does the warranty cover?
The warranty coverage includes:
- Main unit protection: Full three-year manufacturer warranty
- Battery coverage: Included within the main unit warranty
- Repair and replacement: Covered defects and manufacturing issues
What about accessories?
Accessory coverage operates under different terms, with both devices offering 90-day warranties on accessories such as:
- Carrying cases and bags
- Power adapters and charging cables
- Nasal cannulas and tubing
- Additional batteries purchased separately
This warranty structure ensures long-term device support, giving you peace of mind when selecting either concentrator for your oxygen therapy needs. The three-year coverage period aligns with typical replacement cycles for portable oxygen concentrators, allowing you to maximise your device’s lifespan whilst maintaining reliable therapeutic support. You should register your device promptly after purchase to activate warranty protection and maintain detailed records of your purchase date. It’s also important to note that accessory warranties are separate from the main unit warranty, adding an extra layer of protection for your additional purchases. Check out more about Philips Respironics EverFlo: Why It’s a Trusted Oxygen Therapy Device.
What Additional Features Differentiate Philips SimplyGo From Inogen One?
Device alerts and safety features set these two portable oxygen concentrators apart in meaningful ways. The Philips SimplyGo incorporates sophisticated monitoring capabilities that enhance user safety during travel and daily activities. Its advanced alert system includes high breath rate detection, which monitors your breathing patterns and alerts you to potential respiratory distress. The device also features no breath detection technology and low oxygen level warnings, creating multiple layers of protection for users who depend on consistent oxygen therapy.
The SimplyGo’s travel-friendly functions extend beyond basic portability. These comprehensive safety alerts prove particularly valuable when you’re away from medical supervision, whether travelling domestically or internationally. The device continuously monitors your oxygen levels and breathing patterns, providing peace of mind during extended trips or outdoor activities.
Inogen One G3 takes a different approach to user notifications, focusing on essential operational alerts. Its visual and audible warning system covers no breath detection, low battery status, and service requirements. These straightforward alerts keep you informed about device performance without overwhelming complexity.
Maintenance ease represents a significant advantage for the Inogen One G3. This device has built a reputation for robustness and simplified upkeep requirements. Users consistently report fewer maintenance issues and easier cleaning procedures compared to more complex systems. The G3’s streamlined design reduces the number of components requiring regular attention, making it an excellent choice for users who prefer minimal device management responsibilities.
How Air Liquide Healthcare Supports Users of These Oxygen Concentrators
Air Liquide Healthcare services have established a comprehensive support network across Australia since 1995, positioning the company as a leading respiratory care provider for patients requiring oxygen therapy equipment. Their extensive homecare support Australia network spans 152 diagnostic and therapy service locations, serving tens of thousands of home oxygen and sleep apnoea patients nationwide.
The company’s commitment to delivering high-quality products and services extends to both the Philips SimplyGo vs Inogen One: Comparing Leading Oxygen Concentrators selection process and ongoing patient support. Air Liquide Healthcare’s experienced team assists patients in:
- Equipment selection based on individual medical requirements and lifestyle needs
- Professional setup and training on proper device operation and maintenance
- 24/7 technical support for troubleshooting and emergency assistance
- Regular maintenance services to ensure optimal device performance
- Supply management for consumables and replacement parts
As part of a global network serving 3.8 million patients across 75 countries with 66,400 employees, Air Liquide Healthcare combines local expertise with international resources. This dual approach ensures patients receive personalised care whilst benefiting from advanced respiratory technologies and proven clinical protocols developed through decades of experience in medical gas and equipment provision. Such an extensive operation not only highlights the company’s capability but also emphasizes the importance of effective infection control measures in ensuring patient safety during the use of respiratory care equipment.
Which Portable Oxygen Concentrator Should Patients Choose?
Your choice between the Philips SimplyGo and Inogen One depends entirely on your specific oxygen therapy requirements and lifestyle needs.
Choose the Philips SimplyGo if you:
- Require continuous flow oxygen delivery for nighttime use
- Need higher oxygen output levels (up to 2000 ml/min)
- Can manage the additional weight for enhanced therapeutic capabilities
Select the Inogen One G3 if you:
- Only need pulse dose delivery during active hours
- Prioritise maximum portability at 4.8 pounds
- Value extended battery life up to 8 hours
- Prefer quieter operation under 39 decibels
Both devices offer three-year warranties and proven reliability. Consult your healthcare provider to determine which oxygen delivery mode suits your prescription requirements, then consider how each device’s weight, battery life, and features align with your daily activities and travel plans.